| space Press Releases, News Stories |
|
Sierra Club of Canada Press Release OTTAWA, Canada, 16 January 2001 -- The latest ruling from a NAFTA tribunal set up to evaluate claims by S. D. Myers against the Canadian governmenthave far reaching implications for Canadian policy and the interpretation of trade rules say the Canadian Alliance for Trade and the Environment. In a written submission to the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, the Alliance says that the rulingseriously compromises Canada’s international obligations and domestic law on hazardous waste treatment, and should be reviewed by the courts. “Canada will be fined upto $50 million U.S. for honoring commitments that we have under the Basel Convention,” said Elizabeth May, Executive Director of the Sierra Club ofCanada. “The Basel Convention was explicitly negotiated between 130 countries to restrict the cross-border trade and traffic in hazardous waste.” The SD Myers Chapter 11 claim is the first ruling where national obligations under a multilateral environmental agreementhave been disregarded in favor of trade rules. “This is a disaster for environmental policy,” said Steven Shrybman, counsel for the Alliance. “Canada is beingpunished for not facilitating trade in hazardous waste to the United States at a time when it was, in any event, illegal to import PCBs into the United States.” “Investor-state disputes have been disastrous for Canada and Canadian domestic policy,” said Maude Barlow, NationalChairperson of the Council of Canadians.“We are now routinely seeing the roll-back of Canadian domestic regulations to protect health and theenvironment in these panel rulings.” International Trade Minister, Pierre Pettigrew has announced that Canada will not seek investor state provisions in new tradedeals, like the impending FTAA largely because of the damage that has been done to Canadian domestic policy as a result of these secret tribunals. “The Minister’s doubts about an investor-state provision
in the FTAA shows that the government made a grave mistake inaccepting
NAFTA Chapter ll on investor-state disputes. However, there are many
things the government can do, before renegotiating Chapter ll. One
is torefuse recognition of jurisdiction when cases fall outside the scope
of what Chapter ll intended - namely to protect investors from the arbitrary
actions of autocraticgovernments. The other is to appeal blatantly
wrong decisions, as in the case of SD Myers,” said David Bennett of the
Canadian Labour Congress.
Contact information Canadian Labour Congress, (613) 521-3400 Council
of Canadians, (613) 233-4487 Sierra Club of Canada, (613) 241-4611 Sierra
Youth Coalition, (613) 241-1615
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. The Basel Action Network is making this article available in our efforts to advance understanding of ecological sustainability and environmental justice issues. We believe that this constitutes a `fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond `fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. More News |